Clair Freeman

Senior Account Director

Reality Check: Are we comparing schools fairly?

June 17th 2026

Tes recently reported that Ofsted will update its inspection toolkits to clarify how inspectors should consider disadvantage.

The debate feels particularly relevant for trust leaders because it raises an important question: are we measuring schools in the right way?

For years, school performance has largely been judged against national benchmarks. On the surface, that sounds fair. Every school is working towards the same standards, after all. But the reality is often much more complex.

At a recent headteachers’ conference, His Majesty’s Chief Inspector Martin Oliver challenged the idea that some children simply won’t reach expected standards, describing this as a “quiet curse of low expectation”. He argued that this can stem from a lack of honest assessment, and that stronger, more contextualised evidence helps schools drive meaningful improvement.

It’s a powerful message. Yet what struck me when reading about Ofsted’s emerging approach is that inspections may be moving towards a more contextual understanding of performance rather than relying solely on national comparisons.

In practice, that could mean inspectors considering how a school performs compared with genuinely similar schools, not just the national average.

There is a strong case for this approach.

Take a school serving a community with high levels of deprivation, lower levels of parental educational attainment, or significant attendance challenges. Another school may have developed a reputation for supporting pupils with SEND, resulting in a much higher proportion of children with additional needs than neighbouring schools.

In both cases, outcomes alone may not tell the full story.

A school’s results might sit below national averages, leading observers to assume weaknesses in teaching or leadership. Yet when viewed in the context of schools facing similar challenges, a very different picture could emerge. The school where I govern actually experienced this during their most recent inspection. Thankfully, the inspection team were able to investigate further to challenge their own assumptions and find that the pupils made good progress.

Research increasingly highlights the importance of context. Recent analysis has shown that almost half of the disadvantage gap is already established by age 11, reinforcing how strongly wider social factors influence educational outcomes before pupils even reach secondary school. Other studies have demonstrated how children from disadvantaged backgrounds can see their early high attainment eroded over time, despite strong starts in education.

None of this suggests lowering expectations. Every child deserves access to excellent teaching, ambitious curricula and the opportunity to achieve highly. But it does raise legitimate questions about how performance should be evaluated and what constitutes a fair comparison.

Of course, contextual benchmarking brings its own challenges.

If schools are increasingly compared against similar institutions, how will those comparisons be defined? Which factors will matter most? Deprivation? SEND levels? English as an Additional Language? Attendance patterns? Local demographics?

There is also the question of consistency. Will inspectors use this information in the same way, or will it become another area where professional judgement plays a significant role? Will the changes help combat unconscious bias, or potentially increase it? We will have to wait for further clarity on how this will work in practice.

And perhaps most importantly, could this create an unintended two-tier system, where schools are assessed through different lenses depending on their circumstances?

These questions become even more significant when viewed alongside the ongoing curriculum and assessment review, as well as the wider changes proposed within the inspection framework. School accountability appears to be entering a period of considerable change.

For trusts, this is where having the right data becomes increasingly important.

Many trusts already use Assembly to compare schools within their own organisation, often identifying meaningful patterns between schools serving similar communities. Where schools share comparable levels of deprivation, diversity or pupil need, those comparisons can provide much richer insight than national averages alone.

The next challenge for the sector is how to build on that principle more broadly. If accountability frameworks are moving towards greater contextualisation, leaders will need confidence that they are comparing like with like and understanding performance within the right context.

Ultimately, Ofsted’s role is to provide an independent assessment of what it sees and to hold schools accountable for the quality of education they provide. In theory, that accountability exists for the benefit of children. Strong teaching, effective leadership and robust support systems should all lead to better outcomes for pupils.

The question is whether the measures we use are helping us achieve that goal.

If more contextual evidence enables a fairer understanding of school performance and helps leaders focus on meaningful improvement rather than headline comparisons, then this shift could be a positive step forward.

But as with any major change, the success of the approach will depend not just on the data available, but on how consistently and thoughtfully it is used.

How can we help you?

Whether you work in a school or trust of any size, a local authority or a technology provider for education, our friendly team are waiting to hear from you.

We’d love to chat about your goals and how we can support you.